Accountio / Templates / Independent contractors / Worker classification checklist

Worker classification checklist: employee or independent contractor

Decide whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor before the work starts, and keep a record of why. This worker classification checklist is one Word document with 15 questions on the IRS common-law factors, a decision box and a list of what to keep on file.

US firms
$15
In the pack
Independent contractor pack
Files
4, Word
Buy the pack · $15
US library · 52 packs

Get this pack and 51 more for $79

Independent contractors · this packBookkeeping and advisory lettersAudit and AUP lettersBook-to-tax reconciliationCompilation and review lettersCPA verification letters1040 checklistsIRS noticesSales tax nexus+ 43 more
$79$69889% off
Buy the US library · $79

Want every pack, for every region? Global library, 110 packs, $99

What the checklist looks like

Worker classification checklist template
What the checklist coversSection in the checklist
Who and what is being assessed
✓
Business, Worker, Completed byBusiness, worker, the work to be done, and who completed the checklist and when
Control over how the work is done
✓
1. Behavioral controlWhen and where, tools, helpers, supplies, order of work and training
Control over the business side
✓
2. Financial controlOwn costs, own investment, other clients, how the worker is paid and the chance of profit or loss
How the parties see the relationship
✓
3. Type of relationshipWritten contract, benefits, a set project or period, and whether the work is a key part of the business
A tick for each answer
✓
Contractor, EmployeeEach answer points one way, so the pattern shows at a glance
The count and the decision
✓
4. DecisionContractor, employee or unclear, with the main reasons
What happens next
✓
4. DecisionW-9 and Form 1099-NEC, payroll and Form W-2, or a Form SS-8 request
Evidence of an independent business
✓
5. Keep on fileWebsite, other clients, insurance certificate and the signed agreement
Consistent reporting
✓
5. Keep on fileForms 1099-NEC filed for the worker each year
Section 530 relief
✓
5. Keep on fileReasonable basis, consistent treatment of similar workers and every Form 1099 filed
Review and sign-off
✓
Reviewed byName, signature and date

When you need it

The IRS expects a business to look at the whole relationship, weigh all the factors and document the ones it used to reach its decision. No single factor decides it. Complete the checklist when:

  • You engage a freelancer, consultant or other contractor for the first time
  • A contractor's role grows, with set hours, your equipment or no end date
  • A former employee comes back to do similar work as a contractor
  • A client asks you, as their accountant, whether a worker belongs on payroll

How to use the worker classification checklist

  1. Fill in the heading. Name the business, the worker and the work, and who is completing the checklist.
  2. Answer every question. Tick the contractor or the employee box, based on how the work will be done in practice, not only on what the contract says.
  3. Count the answers. Record how many point each way, then weigh them. No set number of answers makes a worker an employee.
  4. Record the decision and the reasons. Contractor, employee or unclear. For an unclear case, the business or the worker can file Form SS-8.
  5. Keep the evidence. File the signed checklist with the agreement and proof of the worker's own business, and complete a new one if the role changes.

Questions

How does the IRS decide if a worker is an employee or a contractor?

It looks at evidence of control and independence in three groups: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. The key question is how far the business has the right to direct and control the worker. No single factor decides it.

What are the three categories of the common-law test?

Behavioral: does the business control what the worker does and how? Financial: does it control the business side, such as how the worker is paid, expenses and tools? Type of relationship: is there a written contract or employee-type benefits, will it continue, and is the work a key part of the business?

What happens if you misclassify an employee as a contractor?

If you have no reasonable basis for treating the worker as a contractor, you can be held liable for the employment taxes for that worker under section 3509.

What is Section 530 relief?

Relief from employment taxes for a business that had a reasonable basis for not treating a worker as an employee, filed all required information returns on that basis, and has not treated any worker in a substantially similar position as an employee. It does not make the worker a contractor.

What is Form SS-8?

The form a business or a worker files to ask the IRS to decide the worker's status for federal employment taxes and income tax withholding. A determination can take at least six months.

Is a remote worker a contractor?

Not because they work remotely. A remote worker is an employee under the common-law rules if you can control what will be done and how, even if the worker chose to work remotely.

Also in the independent contractor pack

Independent contractor agreementContractor onboarding checklist

See the whole pack →

Who it's for

CPA firms, bookkeepers and small business owners in the US who engage freelancers, consultants and other contractors.

Last checked

Checked against IRS guidance on independent contractors and employees and on Form SS-8 in November 2026.